Insert vs. full-frame window replacement
An insert fits inside the existing window frame. Full-frame replacement removes the old frame to the rough opening. Choose based on the condition of each opening and the work needed to fix it.
Reviewed
What changes at the opening?
| Decision | Insert replacement | Full-frame replacement |
|---|---|---|
| What stays | Existing frame stays, when sound and suitable for an insert. | Existing frame comes out to expose the rough opening. |
| When to consider it | The frame is sound and square, and the installer can seal the unit and preserve the needed opening. | The frame is damaged, the opening needs changes, or the installer needs access to treat water entry at the rough opening. |
| Check before ordering | Measure the proposed clear opening and ask how the insert will be sealed and drained. | Ask for rough opening preparation, flashing, air sealing and interior and exterior finish work in writing. |
Is full frame worth it if the sill is rotting?
Ask the installer to identify the water source and extent of the damage. If the old frame or adjoining opening needs repair, full-frame work can provide access. Get a written scope and a change-order rate for damage exposed during removal. If some frames are sound, request separate prices for those openings.
Ask both contractors these questions
- Which existing parts stay, and which are removed at each opening?
- What will the clear opening be, including any required emergency escape opening?
- How will you manage water and air at the window and surrounding wall?
- Who repairs interior trim, siding, masonry or stucco, and how is hidden damage priced?
- Who handles any approvals and inspections for changes to the opening?