How to compare window replacement warranties

Check product coverage, installer labor and service costs in writing before deciding between replacement window quotes.

Reviewed

What should a window warranty tell you?

Ask for the manufacturer’s document for your exact series and the installer’s written workmanship terms. Check who pays for the part, labor and service visit if the glass seal fails, and who handles a leak caused by installation. Compare the remedy and exclusions alongside the number of years.

What to ask about on each quote

TermQuestion to get answered in writing
Product and glassWhich glass seal, non-glass parts and finishes are covered? Is accidental breakage treated differently from a material defect?
Labor and serviceWho pays for diagnosis, shipping, removal, installation and any finish work needed for a covered claim?
Installation workmanshipWho investigates a leak around the frame and what will that installer repair if the cause is their work?
Coverage period and transferWhen does coverage start? What does “lifetime” mean here? Can the next owner claim, and must they notify anyone by a deadline?
Making a claimWho is the first contact and what proof of purchase, serial numbers or installation records should you keep?

Example: replacement glass and labor

For a covered glass defect under Andersen’s October 2023 limited warranty for specified 400 and 200 Series products, Andersen can choose among several remedies. In the replacement-glass option, the manufacturer supplies the glass and excludes labor. Ask whether the warranty documents on your bid include separate labor coverage. Read the Andersen warranty example (PDF).

Hypothetical cost for one covered claim. Both warranties cover the glass part, with no other fees. A covers a $250 labor charge and B leaves it to the homeowner. The out-of-pocket cost is $0 under A and $250 under B, a $250 difference on this claim. Compare this potential cost separately from the original installation quotes.

Pella’s warranty directory separates terms by product and purchase date. Keep the warranty documents that apply to the products in your signed quote.

Who do you call about an existing window?

Find the model or serial number and proof of purchase. Ask the manufacturer or installer named in your warranty who assesses the problem, which remedy they can offer and what you would pay. Get that answer before authorizing repair work.

Sources